Your manager says it proudly: "My door is always open." And they genuinely believe it. They have even arranged the furniture so the door faces the corridor. The problem is that in ten years of management, only three people have ever walked through it with a genuine concern. Everyone else uses WhatsApp to complain to each other.
The "open door policy" is one of the most popular and most useless concepts in modern management. It sounds democratic. It sounds accessible. It shifts the entire burden of communication onto the person with the least power. It says: "I am available if you come to me" — while ignoring the dozen reasons why most employees never will.
Here is why people do not walk through the open door: because they have watched what happens to people who do. The colleague who raised a concern and was labelled a "troublemaker." The team member who gave honest feedback in a meeting and was never invited to another one. The junior who reported a problem and, three months later, found their contract not renewed. These events may be rare, but they are remembered vividly. And one bad outcome is enough to shut down an entire team's willingness to speak up.
The Power Gap Problem
The fundamental flaw of the open door is that it asks the less powerful person to take the risk. Walking into your boss's office to say "I think you are wrong about this" or "the workload is unsustainable" or "your favourite employee is bullying the team" requires enormous courage. Most people — rationally — decide it is not worth the risk. The potential downside (being punished, marginalised, or dismissed) outweighs the potential upside (being heard and having something change). So they say nothing. And the manager concludes: "Nobody has any complaints. Things must be fine." Things are not fine. People are just afraid.
What Works Instead
If you genuinely want to know what your team is thinking, you cannot wait for them to come to you. You have to go to them. Not in a surveillance way — in a genuine, curious way:
- One-on-ones that are actually about them. Not project updates. Real conversations. "What is frustrating you right now? What would make your job easier? Is there anything you want me to know that you have not felt comfortable saying?"
- Anonymous feedback channels. Some things people will only say if they cannot be identified. An anonymous survey, suggestion box (physical or digital), or third-party feedback platform removes the fear of retaliation.
- Acting on what you hear. This is the critical step that most organisations skip. If you ask for feedback and then nothing changes, you have taught people that feedback is pointless. Next time you ask, they will not bother.
Close the door. Open a real conversation instead. The difference between a manager who knows what is happening and a manager who does not is not the door. It is the willingness to ask uncomfortable questions and sit with uncomfortable answers.